Tuesday, May 24, 2016

Building Materials and the Time Value of Carbon

When you save matters. What you build matters.
Here’s why we need to build well and rebuild better.


By Larry Strain

The Paris climate accord set a new target for global temperature rise: to keep global temperatures from rising above 2°C and thus avoid catastrophic, irreversible climate change. The countries of the world came together and set a more aggressive goal of 1.5°C temperature rise. To meet that goal, emissions need to peak by 2020, and fossil fuels need to be phased out by 2055.

Given those goals, there are two critical things we need to consider when we evaluate carbon reduction strategies:
  • The first is the amount of potential savings a strategy offers.
  • The second is the time frame of those savings.
We need strategies that produce large savings quickly, and because some reduction strategies result in an initial increase in carbon emissions, we need to pursue strategies that can produce a net reduction within that critical 10- to 20-year time frame.

Over the last year, a group of us from Siegel & Strain Architects, the Carbon Leadership Forum, and Architecture 2030 have been working to build connections between individuals and organizations working on different strategies for reducing GHG emissions in the built environment. Recognizing that we don’t have much time left to address climate change, we are focusing on strategies that can deliver the largest reductions in the shortest time.

These strategies include:
  • reducing embodied greenhouse gas emissions from materials and construction
  • reusing and retrofitting existing buildings
  • building new net-zero-energy buildings
 See below for how you can get involved.

The scale of the problem

As an end user of fossil fuels, the built environment accounts for more emissions than any other single sector—somewhere between 40% and 50% of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.

The current gold standard for reducing emissions from buildings is to build new, net-zero-energy (NZE) buildings—super-efficient buildings powered by renewable energy sources. This is an important piece of getting to a carbon-neutral built environment, but there is a problem with this strategy: building those new NZE buildings will generate a lot of emissions.

Two other sources of emissions may be even more important to address in the short term:
  • embodied emissions from building materials, products, and construction processes
  • operating emissions from the buildings we already have.

Embodied emissions (eCO2) in new construction

Embodied emissions are the first emissions a building generates.
In the U.S., we are currently building about 5.7 billion ft2 of new buildings a year, and the embodied emissions from building those new buildings is about 300 million metric tons per year.

Over the next 20 years, the embodied emissions from those new buildings will outweigh the operating emissions from those buildings. And if we manage to make them NZE, then the only emissions will be the embodied emissions. So while new buildings need be NZE, we also need to reduce embodied emissions.

Based on Siegel & Strain’s own experience with building low-carbon buildings, we know we can reduce embodied emissions by around 30% by selecting existing materials and technology, by using lower-carbon materials, and by employing more-efficient design and construction processes. But an even more effective way to reduce embodied emissions is to reuse existing buildings. Building renovation generates significantly less emissions than new construction does and creates an opportunity to reduce operating emissions from existing buildings.

Operating Emissions  (oCO2) in existing buildings

Operating emissions from existing buildings are an even bigger source of emissions. There are about 310 billion ft2 of buildings in the United States, and operating them generates about 2.2 billion metric tons of GHG emissions every year—about one-third of total U.S. GHG emissions. The majority of the buildings in use today will still be in use in 2030, so existing buildings are the buildings we need to improve.

Which brings us back to the strategy of renovating more existing buildings and building fewer new buildings.

When the renovations include deep energy upgrades—even making them NZE buildings—we address two sources of GHG missions at the same time. We reduce embodied emissions compared to new buildings, and we reduce operating emissions from existing buildings.  And the good news is, we already know how to do this:
  • Improve efficiency: upgrade the lighting, HVAC systems, equipment, controls, etc.
  • Improve the building envelope: insulation, windows, shading, air sealing, daylighting.
  • Power them with renewable energy.

NZE remodels are not as hard as we might think. We just co-authored the Total Carbon Study, a detailed case study of a two-story office remodel and upgrade that is now generating more energy that it consumes—a net-positive building. This interior remodel upgraded equipment and lighting, and added skylights and photovoltaics (PV), with only minimal upgrades to the envelope (roof insulation). The remodel generated about one-third of the embodied emissions that rebuilding the building would have.

For NZE retrofits, we need to evaluate the initial eCO2 investment against the savings from the upgrade. How much carbon was invested to get to zero, and how long will it take the savings from increased efficiency to offset that investment?

When you do this analysis, the answers may surprise you. Blowing in insulation or re-commissioning existing HVAC and lighting systems are likely good investments of eCO2; re-skinning a building with a high-performance aluminum and glass curtain wall may not be worth it. We need to start evaluating all of our reduction strategies by how well they perform within a 10- to 20-year time frame.

Shifting Priorities

It’s time to rethink our goals for reducing emissions from the built environment:
  • Make all new buildings net zero by 2030.
  • Reduce embodied emissions from new buildings to zero by 2050.
  • Upgrade all existing buildings to net zero by 2050.
  • Prioritize early savings over long-term savings.
I want to clarify a few things:
  1. Yes, we still need new buildings. Buildings wear out, priorities change, and populations shift and grow. That said, we could be reusing a lot more buildings than we currently do.
  2. Every existing building won’t get to net zero. We need to identify and target the best candidates and focus on them first. Low-rise commercial and residential buildings are high on my list. We could be retrofitting a lot more buildings to very low energy or NZE.
  3. Reusing and upgrading existing buildings makes more sense in places that are mostly developed, like the U.S. and the EU. For countries that are still building a lot of new buildings, like China and India, the focus will need to be more on reducing the embodied carbon in new construction (as well as making these new buildings NZE).

Larry Strain, FAIA, is principal at Siegel & Strain Architects. Erin McDade, program manager at Architecture 2030, and Kate Simonen, AIA, S.E., founding director of the Carbon Leadership Forum, contributed to this article.

If you are working on these issues and would like to be on the contact list this group is developing, please contact Erin McDade at Architecture 2030.



  1. Thanks for the useful information. In today's era What you build that matters. Architects

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  4. I admire this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much. Read more info about Curtain Wall System

  5. I am doing a report on this subject. Your article is full of really useful information. I will make sure to come back to check out your posts for my next report. reformas integrales zaragoza

  6. I generally want quality content and this thing I found in your article. It is beneficial and significant for us polycarbonate glass. Keep sharing these kinds of articles, Thank you.

  7. The article you've shared here is fantastic because it provides some excellent information about Curtain Wall System that will be incredibly beneficial to me. Thank you for sharing that. Keep up the good work.

  8. I am very thankful to you for sharing this best knowledge with us. This information is helpful for everyone. So please always share this kind of knowledge with everyone. Thanks. Read more info about Aluminium pedestrian gates gold coast

  9. This blog is so nice to me. I will keep on coming here again and again. Visit my link as well.. building villa regina

  10. buy yt views If you're the kind of person who does these sorts of things online: buy ebooks, subscribes to newsletters, register for a free mini course, join a membership website, etc. then you no doubt have noticed a new trend. Bloggers and Internet Marketers alike these days seem to be using videos to help promote and sell their products more than ever before.

  11. I have read your article, it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. Thanks for posting it.. building st regis bal harbour

  12. Excellent knowledge, I am very much thankful to you that you have shared good information with us. Here I got some special kind of knowledge and it is helpful for everyone. Thanks for share it. pls visit our website residential metal buildings texas

  13. I'd like to express my gratitude for writing such an informative piece on this blog. This article provided me with a variety of data about Structural Engineering. Continue to post.

  14. Here you will learn what is important, it gives you a link to an interesting web page: best doctor for lasik surgery in delhi

  15. At this point you'll find out what is important, it all gives a url to the appealing page: Calgary Roofing Companies

  16. building design Thanks for a very interesting blog. What else may I get that kind of info written in such a perfect approach? I’ve a undertaking that I am simply now operating on, and I have been at the look out for such info.

  17. This is a fabulous post I seen because of offer it. It is really what I expected to see trust in future you will continue in sharing such a mind boggling post Leaking balcony

  18. Welcome to the party of my life here you will learn everything about me. Satta king game

  19. The popularity of playing Satta king online in India is increasing day by day. Some people play Satta games offline, some people play Satta games using internet. He wants to get rich quick. If you want to play Satta or you want to gain knowledge about satta king, then you must read this article because I will give you complete information about all kinds of entities, advantages or disadvantages related to Satta king.

  20. As well as assisting the rooftop with remaining longer and more grounded against outside unforgiving components, certain rooftop sheeting materials are known to be great protection against hotness and cold. Colorbond cladding

  21. I always check this type of advisory post and I found your article which is related to my interest. This is a great way to increase knowledge for us. Thanks for sharing an article like this.San Antonio Roofers

  22. Very well written article. It was an awesome article to read. Read more info about engineering consulting. Complete rich content and fully informative. I totally Loved it.

  23. Assuming this occurs on your material substitution, you will feel a ton better it is clung to know that your material project worker. coquitlam roofing contractors

  24. The information in the post you posted here is useful because it contains some of the best information available. Thanks for sharing it. Keep up the good work consultants for engineering projects.

  25. In this respect, it acts as a helmet for your home. Another way it protects your home is through its insulative qualities. roofrepairinsider.com

  26. You've provided some very useful information. I'm glad I came into this article because it provides a lot of important information. Thank you for sharing this storey with us. Roofing Tpo

  27. You are giving a particularly useful article here. You have depicted all that which is effectively reasonable to everybody. Continue to share this sort of articles, Thank you.Roof Restorations Canberra

  28. Austin is a city that loves its houses clean. And since it's not always possible for the residents to clean their own houses, they've turned to a professional cleaning company. house cleaning checklist app austin

  29. The time value of carbon refers to the idea that the impact of carbon emissions on the environment varies depending on when those emissions occur. In essence, carbon emissions released today have a greater impact on climate change than emissions released in the future. This concept underscores the importance of reducing carbon emissions now to mitigate their long-term effects on the environment.
    divorce lawyers in virginia